had no idea it was creating such a buzz.
As I sat there listening to her interview, by the way, which could have lasted longer...I said to myself, "finally, someone in the mainstream who's not afraid to challenge the 'modern' way of parenting, without being afraid of getting their head ripped off". Since "Tiger Mom" put out her first book, I thought no one else dared to come out with something that challenges the "world's view" on parenting. But oh was I wrong. And you can best believe my wheels were spinning! As you can probably tell, after writing this post...I'm going out to buy this book(that is if my husband doesn't beat me to the punch - he reads more than anyone I know).
Back to the book. Since I didn't have an actual copy in my hand you know I had to go Google it. I read the reviews, some of course were not favorable, as in anything that goes against the "status quo". But, before I get into MY thoughts on modern parenting...here's an excerpt from the forward....
"Thousands of books have examined the effects of parents on their children. But almost none have thought to ask: what are the effects of children on their parents? In All Joy and No Fun, award-winning journalist Jennifer Senior isolates and analyzes the many ways in which children reshape their parents' lives, whether it's their marriages, their jobs, their habits, their hobbies, their friendships, or their internal senses of self. She argues that changes in the last half century have radically altered the roles of today's mothers and fathers, making their mandates at once more complex and far less clear. Recruiting from a wide variety of sources-in history, sociology, economics, psychology, philosophy, and anthropology-she dissects both the timeless strains of parenting and the ones that are brand new, and then brings her research to life in the homes of ordinary parents around the country. The result is an unforgettable series of family portraits, starting with parents of young children and progressing to parents of teens. Through lively and accessible storytelling, Senior follows these mothers and fathers as they wrestle with some of parenthood's deepest vexations-and luxuriate in some of its finest rewards.
Meticulously researched yet imbued with emotional intelligence, All Joy and No Fun makes us reconsider some of our culture's most basic beliefs about parenthood, all while illuminating the profound ways children deepen and add purpose to our lives. By focusing on parenthood, rather than parenting, the book is original and essential reading for mothers and fathers of today-and tomorrow."
This was such a breath of fresh air for me. I'm all gung ho, as I haven't actually read the book yet. And there will probably be something in it(as with most books I read) that I won't agree with. BUT, it has gotten the dialogue started on why as a society, we're digressing. I'm not saying that Mrs. Senior's book is the answer to the decline of our society, but it's a start.
I for one, come from the "old school" fabric of parenting. I'm the one who reads Dr. John Rosemond's Sunday column and give him an air high five for having the guts to say what deep down inside, we all know to be the truth. Listen, some of the advice can be to the extreme, as let's be honest here...some parents aren't equipped to make fair, rational and reasonable child rearing decisions when it comes to their children. THAT in itself is a very sad thing. But, that in no way means we should throw out the baby with the bath water! What's right is right and what's wrong is wrong....right?
For instance, if a child is in the store rolling on the floor having a temper tantrum. You just don't throw up your hands and let them do it! NO! Boundaries should have been set waaay before that even takes place. I, in no way think ANYTHING is cute about a child sassing or saying no to a parent. Even at the cute age of 1 or 2. Contrary to what some parents think...children.are.not.stupid! In fact, they're VERY smart! And they also know what they can and can't get away with! If boundaries are set and they already know what's expected and the consequences that come with it...BELIEVE ME, they may try - but they're smart enough to know what the ramifications are that follow. Why do you think a teacher can get an entire classroom of kids to follow rules(sure you'll have a few that will buck the system), but the majority of them won't. She has a set of rules and a set of consequences and if they deviate, they get the punishment. And eventually they learn. It doesn't take rocket science. It takes patience AND consistency. And you don't have to scream and yell either to get your point across(aside from the occasional 'clean your room or else'), lol. But seriously, children WANT boundaries and discipline...why, because it's a security and a stability to them. They know they have someone in the mix who's smart enough and bold enough to have their backs and center them when it looks like the world is falling apart.
We as parents have tired ourselves out parenting, because we try to be EVERYTHING to our kids. Their friend, their confidant, their play date, their everything. Hey some of you may love that, but I'm not the one. And NO, my kids aren't some warped basket cases, because I wasn't all those things to them. As a matter of fact they thank us for giving them a reality check concerning life. And they'll be the first to tell you they had a wonderful childhood filled with love and laughter. Listen, they had their fair share of movie, museum, park, zoo and library outings to last them a lifetime. But, I didn't drop what I was doing to run to their every beck and call either. If they wanted to play, that's what they had siblings and friends for. That's what God gave them an imagination for. And please don't get it twisted, I wasn't some "Mommy Dearest" mother who shunned her kids and showed no nurture. No way! As a matter of fact, I(we) showered them with love and affection(my husband would say I was overbearing in that category, lol)...still do, but I never, ever let them get confused as to whose role was whose. And our(my husband and I) relationship with them is one of the closest I've ever seen. It has made them independent, self-confident adults, who make wise choices concerning their lives.
I've said all that to say, that our parents and grandparents raised a house full of kids. They didn't have all the books and psychology we have today, but we turned out okay, didn't we? They had to rely on their parenting instincts and not on what some book told them to do. They had to come up with a game plan that not only protected their children, but also preserved their sanctity, their energy and their time. I'm not saying we can't have fun with our kids and make memorable moments. My motto has been and will always be...if it ain't broke, you can tweak it, but don't fix it! God gave us the job of parenting and we're to do our very best. We're not going to get brownie points for how many times we let them have what they wanted or what we gave them materially, but we'll be judged on how well we steward their lives.
Colossians 3:21, Ephesians 6:4, Proverbs 29:15, Proverbs 22:6, I Corinthians 3:10-15, Genesis 18:19
SN...the "Doing YOU WELL Wednesday" link up will only be hosted the last Wednesday of each month, starting this month. Please join me next Wednesday!
All Rights Reserved copyright© 2012-2014 Michell Pulliam “Prowess and
Pearls” by Michell Pulliam
OMGEEE (says the 40 yr old :) ) This is so true and profound. I'm so for the 'old school" parenting style. I had a parent of a sassy mouth teenager respond to my correcting my then, 5 yr old on her manners... say "she's only 5, it's ok if she says that". I really wanted to tell her that the actions I'm taking now...is to prevent my child speaking like hers when she's older...
ReplyDeleteI love my children dearly, and its a lot of work and effort to keep them in line (sometimes I'm just tired) but I remind myself that a healthy balance of fun and consequence/discipline is gonna payoff later. I'm tweeking... Great post
Yes Hope, it sure will! I see it all the time too, parents wondering what could have gone wrong with their kids...ummm ma'am it probably started way back then when you thought their behavior was cute and didn't correct it. They don't remain "little" forever. One day they do grow up and become bigger...unfortunately by then it's too late!
DeleteI so agree - it's amazing the way kids act today! boundaries are everything!
ReplyDeleteThey are aren't they Bekah! Anything that is not governed or properly taken care of will have to fend for itself. We all know what happens to kids who have to do that. Thanks for stopping by!
DeleteBe blessed.
ReplyDeleteYou too Denise!
DeleteMichell, this is such a great post!-I really enjoyed this!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much Stephanie! Have a good one my friend! ;-)
DeleteExcept for the first year when I had my nose in every chapter of Christopher's development, I have relied on my instincts. The foreword of that book does sound interesting and different but I just cannot read a book on parenting. I think about how I was raised and how I want to be the same in some areas and different in others. And I think I turned out alright and hope the same for Christopher ;-) I think consistency is a big key in parenting.
ReplyDeleteHey Kenya! I know what you mean girl, I haven't read a parenting book as of yet, but this one sounds interesting, lol! Like you, I like to think my parents did a great job raising me and my sisters(I think I turned out pretty okay too), lol! Yes, there are some things I did differently, but I didn't steer too far away from the values they taught. Yep, consistency is KEY! Thanks for chiming in Kenya...have a good one!
DeleteThank you for such a well-written post based on the WORD!
ReplyDeleteMichell it has been FAR too long since I visited your blog. This is such a great post, and I am really looking forward to reading the book as well. I agree with you on boundaries, and I would say that consistency is a huge part of it as well. I really struggle with this because my husband pretty much does the opposite of everything I am trying to do. I have found that my daughter will start to pitch a fit about something, but if I hold strong, she'll back down. My husband on the other hand, gives right into her. It's very frustrating! Parenting is tough, and I just hope that I am doing "good enough" in shepherding them!
ReplyDeleteHi Michell! I know that after a tense discussion with my teenager, he finally came out with "I want you to be my friend, not my parent!" Half of me wanted to be his friend too. It's a lot easier!! But I had to tell him that wasn't going to happen for a long time.
ReplyDeleteNow he's almost thirty, and we are getting closer to that. Parenting is very hard, and I love the perspective of what children do that shapes their parents and marriage. That would be an interesting read.
Thank you for letting us all know about the book!
Ceil
Parenting sure feels like a minefield these days. There is criticism everywhere you turn, and what was once considered a common "norm" is no longer accepted practice. I encourage all parents out there to be loving, patient... and firm. And of course, it all boils down to consistency, which frankly is just hard! Great post:)
ReplyDeleteHA! I love that tweak it but don't fix it! You know we are like minded in this even though I am not a parent. I am one of few of my friends that aren't so I'm watching all the different parenting styles and some are on the money and some are a "modern" mess in my opinion. You have surely stepped on some toes with this but I agree with you. The book sounds interesting. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteAll these great parenting books come out now that my kids are almost adults.. *sigh*
ReplyDeleteGreat post!
I want to read this book NOW!!! I love love love the idea behind it! And your parenting style is tried and true my friend... I have no tolerance for disrespect of any kind. Period. Thanks for sharing this book, because apparently I am out of the loop too!! GAH. ;)
ReplyDeleteamen, we are here to parent our children: to guide them and discipline them. we are not here to be there friend or playmate! just like there aren't any bad dogs, just bad dog owners; similarly, there aren't bad children, only bad parents! i feel like parents have become way too lax and give in to their children way too much. it's all about setting limits and showing kids who is boss: US!
ReplyDelete"Prowess and Pearls by Michell Pulliam" has been included in the A Sunday Drive for this week. Be assured that I hope this help to point even more new visitors in your direction.
ReplyDeletehttp://asthecrackerheadcrumbles.blogspot.com/2014/03/a-sunday-drive_23.html
金瓶梅視訊聊天室-日本免費色情直播網站
ReplyDeleteshowlive視訊聊天網-兔費色情視頻直播間
live173-韓國美女視頻直播間
showlive聊天網-成人視訊聊天室網
showlive影音視訊-視頻直播聊天室成人
showlive平台-國外免費開放聊天室
ShowLive影音聊天網-免費裸體美女聊天室
showlive影音視訊聊天網-色情美女視頻聊天網站
showlive-美女裸體免費聊天網站
live173影音live秀-免費視訊-免費女主播聊天室
同城e夜情交友網寂寞小富婆視頻聊天台灣uu真人視頻聊天室成人色情偷拍圖片視訊偷錄正點
免費床友交友網百萬富婆交友俱樂部6699影音視訊聊天室AV淫狐成人三級影片ut視訊設定
同城交友網只為性4758寂寞同城交友台灣uu裸聊視頻看兩性性愛亂倫的小說ut視訊聊天網址
視頻吧聊天交友網虫族同城夜情交友網台灣uu視頻聊天室快播黃色電影網站ut視訊聊天是室
國外在線視頻聊天真人在線裸聊網台灣uu真人裸聊視頻聊天室美女擼管圖片ut視訊美女聊天
live 173影音live秀
ReplyDelete173liveshow視訊
ut視訊聊天室
live173影音
live173影音
live 173
live 173
live 173免費視訊
live 173免費視訊
173視訊
免費國外視頻聊天網比基尼美女胸罩脫落成人做愛綜合網免費成人色情影視視訊偷錄
國外隨機視頻聊天網日本比基尼美女視頻日本成人性交視頻免費毛片快播A片視訊偷錄線上看
交友網站約炮hihi寂寞同城交友網色情亂倫小說影院韓國毛片在線觀看視訊偷錄影片
真愛旅舍日冰寂寞同城交友網線上人間視訊香港毛片成人免費性愛小說黃色3g視訊偷錄
國外視頻交友聊天網中國比基尼美女視頻快播黃色電影影視成人偷拍自拍社區msn 視訊偷錄
173視訊
ReplyDeletelive173視訊聊天交友網
live173視訊聊天交友網
173影音
173影音
173 影音 live 秀免費視訊
live173影音live秀-免費視訊
Live173app
Live173app
LIVE173影音視訊live秀
視訊聊天交友網寂寞人交友網裸聊真人視訊網倫理AV小說圖片手機快播情色網站視訊偷錄軟體
一對一視頻交友彩蓮公主聊天室台灣甜心女孩網站破解黑絲網襪性感美腿圖片視訊偷錄程式
夜店之王視頻秀插件愛情聊視頻社區成人人體熟婦少女免費短篇激情色小說偷錄視訊
美女視頻秀場愛情聊視頻聊天室韓國美女視頻聊天網站賓館嬌妻黑絲網襪誘惑偷錄視訊影片
QQ群視頻帝成聊天室吧美女裸聊視頻秀場色色黃色小說日本動漫性感圖片如何偷錄視訊